In this issue

Features

Bad science and good mental health
Science alone does not provide all theÌýanswers; we also need to acknowledge theÌýinfluence of mind, argues Martin Seager.

Mindfulness for students
Ariana Faris describes how mindfulnessÌýtraining can help students cope withÌýperformance stress.

Clinical hypnosis in practice
Clinical hypnosis can be a useful addition toÌýthe therapist’s repertoire, says John Butler.

Regulars

Talking point
Dominic Davies: Same-sex retraction

In practice
Rachel Freeth: We are human too

News feature
Families in trouble
Does counselling have a place in interventions to help ‘troubled families’ breakÌýfree from the cycle of disadvantage? Catherine Jackson talks to practitionersÌýon the frontline.

Questionnaire
Lynette Harborne

Dilemmas
Caught in the middle

Day in the life
Helena Stuart: We always grow towards potential

Letters

Ïã¸ÛÁùºÏ²Ê¾«×¼×ÊÁÏ

From the chair
Amanda Hawkins: A time for nurture and reflection

Cover of Therapy Today, September 2012

Articles from this issue are not yet available online. Members and subscribers can download the pdf from theÌýTherapy TodayÌýarchive.

Editorial

Martin Seager, author of our cover featureÌýthis month, is sick of hearing counsellorsÌýbeing told that they are unscientific andÌýthat they must jump on the IAPT bandwagonÌýand become evidence-based. In ‘Bad scienceÌýand good mental health’ he wants to give theÌýcounselling profession hope that counsellingÌýculture and science culture can and shouldÌýwork together.

The key to this, as he sees it,Ìýis that the mind needs to be factored in toÌýscience rather than factored out, as it currentlyÌýis. Human minds can never be measuredÌýquantitatively or objectively, he argues.ÌýIAPT itself reflects the ‘bad science’ endemicÌýin our traditional mental health culture –Ìýa pseudo-science that belies our everydayÌýexperience of working with people withÌýmental distress. To understand mental healthÌýscientifically we need to look more closelyÌýat the science of empathy, attachment andÌýrelationship. We know that what transformsÌýpeople in therapy and in life is loving andÌýcaring relationships and Seager wantsÌýcounsellors to retain their belief in theÌýhuman value of what they do and not be groundÌýdown by the power of the medical model.

Counsellors working with the Government’sÌýnewly identified 120,000 ‘troubled families’Ìýsound pretty convinced about the humanÌývalue of their interventions. Interestingly,Ìýnobody in our news feature is suggestingÌýthat these families are trapped in cycles ofÌýdisadvantage and despair due to any biologicalÌýdeficiencies or hereditary illnesses or, indeed,Ìýthat they should be receiving manualisedÌýevidence-based therapies. This is anotherÌýpayment-by-results programme, a case ofÌýdo whatever it takes to improve these people’sÌýlives and stop them draining public resources.ÌýAnd counselling, as you would expect, isÌýplaying an important part. Reading throughÌýLouise Casey’s case histories of troubledÌýmothers, it’s not hard to understand whereÌýthings have gone wrong for these families. AsÌýSue Gerhardt says, if you’ve never experiencedÌýa positive relationship in your life, the cure isÌýto have a positive relationship. Threatening toÌýwithdraw benefits isn’t going to address that.

Sarah Browne
Editor